PART 9 – I Was Still Standing Beside the Christmas Herbs When I Realized Renee Had Told Me Everything Except Why I Was No Longer Welcome

I had asked Renee whether she really meant I should not come.

That was where the conversation had left me.

I was still in the grocery store.

The telephone was pressed against my ear.

My shopping list was in my hand.

And the package of discounted thyme was still sitting in my cart.

I had not moved on to the potatoes.

I had not gone looking for carrots.

I had not checked the price of butter.

I had stopped shopping because I no longer understood what I was shopping for.

Renee had explained the new arrangements.

Her parents would be coming on Christmas Day.

They were expected around noon.

The food had already been taken care of.

Those details were clear enough.

What was not clear was why their arrival meant I should stay away.

I had tried to understand it as a question about the meal.

That was my mistake.

I had assumed that if the potatoes were no longer needed, another dish might be.

I had offered to bring something different.

Renee had not asked for anything.

She had told me it would be preferable if I did not attend.

I kept thinking about how carefully she had introduced the subject.

There had been a change to Christmas.

That was how she had begun.

A change.

Such an ordinary word.

It could have meant almost anything.

A different time.

A different dish.

An extra guest.

I had been ready for any of those things.

I had not been ready to hear that I should not come.

I remembered how quickly I had accepted the news about her mother.

I had thought she was visiting on December twenty-sixth.

Renee said her plans had changed.

I did not challenge that.

I did not ask why.

I simply accepted that she would arrive earlier.

Then I asked about the potatoes.

Looking back, I can see how determined I was to keep the conversation ordinary.

I asked about food because food was something I could understand.

It was something I could change.

If one dish was unnecessary, I could bring another.

If there was already enough for everyone, I could leave the groceries on the shelf.

I did not need a long explanation about any of that.

But being told not to attend Christmas was different.

There was no item on my list that could answer it.

I looked down at the paper.

The four things I had written were still there.

Potatoes.

Carrots.

Butter.

Cranberry sauce.

I had written them because I expected to contribute to the meal.

I had not been trying to make myself important.

I simply thought those things were needed.

Now Renee was telling me they were not.

And neither was my presence.

That last thought hurt.

I did not want to put words into her mouth.

She had not described my presence that way.

She had simply asked me not to come.

But that was how her request felt to me.

I tried to separate my feelings from what I knew.

I knew her parents were coming.

I knew the arrangements were already made.

I knew the food was covered.

I knew she wanted me absent on Christmas Day.

I did not know why.

That distinction mattered.

I could imagine all sorts of explanations.

But none of them had been given to me.

I could not turn my imagination into an answer.

I could not claim to understand a decision I had not been part of.

And I could not make Renee explain herself simply by standing in front of the herbs.

There was another shopping cart moving somewhere nearby.

Its wheels made a faint rattling sound.

The noise reminded me that I was still in a public place.

People were carrying on with their errands.

I was supposed to be doing the same.

Instead, I was standing there trying not to sound upset.

I remember looking at the thyme.

One package had gone into my cart.

The other had gone back onto the shelf.

I had made that decision before I understood what Renee was saying.

It had seemed important to choose carefully.

Now I wondered whether I needed either package.

I did not know what Christmas dinner would look like without me.

I only knew what Renee had told me about it.

Her parents.

Noon.

Food already arranged.

No potatoes from me.

No alternative dish.

No visit on Christmas Day.

Those were the details.

Everything else remained unanswered.

I had spent much of the call trying to offer something useful.

Perhaps that was why I found it so difficult to stop.

I wanted to ask whether I could bring the cranberry sauce anyway.

I wanted to suggest that I could come at another time.

I wanted some small adjustment that would turn the conversation back into a discussion.

But Renee had not asked me to negotiate the arrangements.

She had informed me of them.

I understood that now.

I could accept that her mother had changed her plans.

I could accept that the food was covered.

I could accept that nobody needed the potatoes.

What I could not easily accept was how quickly those ordinary details had become a reason for me to stay away.

I had not expected Christmas to become a question about whether I belonged.

Yet that was the question I was left holding.

I did not have an answer beyond Renee's request.

And I was beginning to understand that I might not get one from this conversation.

The grocery list was still in my hand.

The telephone was still against my ear.

Nothing about the store had changed.

But I could no longer look at the items on that paper as though they were simply things I needed to buy.

They belonged to the Christmas I had expected.

Renee was describing a different Christmas.

One that would go ahead without me.

I wanted to believe there had been a misunderstanding.

I wanted to believe the words had come out wrong.

But I had heard what she said.

And I had asked her whether she meant it.

That was all I could do with the information I had.

I could not invent a better explanation.

I could not pretend the decision had not been made.

I could only acknowledge that the plans were no longer what I had believed.

That was the moment the shopping list stopped feeling useful.

I had come to the store ready to prepare for Christmas dinner.

Now I was standing there with no reason to believe I would be attending it.


Click here to continue reading: PART 10: I Had Gone Shopping for a Christmas Dinner I Expected to Share, but Renee’s Call Left Me Facing an Answer I Could Not Change

Story Parts

I Was Choosing Herbs for Christmas Dinner When Renee Called and Told Me Our Family Had Changed Its Plans

Part 9 of 10

Previous: Part 8
Next: Part 10

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *