PART 8 – I Finally Stopped Thinking About What to Bring for Christmas and Faced the One Decision Renee Had Already Made Without Me

I had been trying to understand the call through the wrong question.

What should I bring?

That was the question I kept asking.

I had started with potatoes.

When Renee said those were no longer needed, I offered something different.

I thought that would settle matters.

It did not.

Because the question Renee was answering was not what I should bring.

It was whether I should come.

By the time I understood that, she had already told me her decision.

I was not supposed to be there on Christmas Day.

I looked down at the package of thyme.

Its yellow label was still visible.

Reduced.

I had chosen it because there was nothing wrong with the leaves.

I had been satisfied with that decision.

It was ordinary.

Something I could explain.

The package looked fine, and it cost less.

That was all.

I wished the conversation with Renee had been as easy to understand.

But she had offered no explanation that connected the arrival of her parents to my exclusion.

Her mother had changed her plans.

Her parents would arrive around noon.

The meal was already arranged.

Those were the facts she gave me.

I could repeat them.

I could remember them.

I could even accept them.

But I could not see why they required me to stay away.

I was still trying to find a reason.

That was what kept me standing beside the herb shelf.

I had not finished the grocery shopping.

I had not crossed anything off my list.

I had not decided what to do with the thyme.

I was still in the middle of an ordinary errand.

And the reason for that errand had just been taken away.

I remember how quickly my thoughts moved from one item to another.

The potatoes were no longer needed.

Neither were the other groceries.

I did not know whether there was anything else I could bring.

Then I realized I had already asked that question.

Renee had answered it.

She did not want another dish.

She did not want me there.

I had been treating those answers as though they were separate.

They were not.

The food was covered because the meal had been arranged without needing my contribution.

And I had been asked to stay away because that was the arrangement Renee was telling me about.

I did not know what reasoning lay behind it.

I could not pretend otherwise.

But the immediate result was plain.

I would not be bringing potatoes to Christmas dinner.

I would not be bringing carrots.

I would not be bringing butter or cranberry sauce.

I had planned to bring those things because I expected to attend.

Now that expectation had been taken away.

I felt foolish for continuing to look at the list.

But I could not seem to put it down.

The paper represented the day I had imagined.

A simple meal.

A family gathering.

The ordinary work of preparing food.

I had never expected a shopping list to become something I would remember so clearly.

Yet there it was.

Four items.

One small piece of paper.

And a telephone call that changed what they meant.

I thought about the way Renee had begun.

She had said they were making a change to Christmas.

It had sounded harmless.

I had not been worried.

Then she explained about her parents.

I had listened.

Then she said the food was covered.

I had offered something else.

Then she said I should stay away.

Each part had seemed like a small step.

Only the last one showed me where the conversation had been going.

I had wanted to return to the beginning.

To ask again what had changed.

To hear the explanation differently.

But the first words were not the problem.

The final request was.

I understood that now.

I was not being asked to adjust the menu.

I was being asked to accept that the day would go ahead without me.

I had not agreed to it beforehand.

I had not been consulted.

I had simply been told.

That was painful enough without inventing explanations I had not heard.

I did not know why Renee wanted it that way.

I did not know whether anyone else knew what she had said to me.

I did not know whether another conversation might change anything.

And I did not know what would happen after Christmas.

Those were questions I could not answer from the telephone call.

The one thing I did know was what Renee had asked.

She wanted me to stay away on Christmas Day.

I had repeated her words because I could hardly believe them.

But repeating them did not change them.

I looked once more at my list.

Potatoes.

Carrots.

Butter.

Cranberry sauce.

I had come into the store expecting to buy those things for a dinner I thought I would attend.

I was still standing there, with the phone at my ear and the discounted thyme in my cart.

Nothing had changed on the shelves.

Nothing had changed on the paper.

The change was in what I now understood.

Renee had not called because she needed me to bring something different.

She had called because she wanted me not to come.

And I could no longer pretend I had misunderstood.


Click here to continue reading: PART 9: I Was Still Standing Beside the Christmas Herbs When I Realized Renee Had Told Me Everything Except Why I Was No Longer Welcome

Story Parts

I Was Choosing Herbs for Christmas Dinner When Renee Called and Told Me Our Family Had Changed Its Plans

Part 8 of 10

Previous: Part 7
Next: Part 9

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *