PART 5 – I Kept Waiting for Renee to Explain Why Christmas Had Changed, but the Only Answer I Had Was Her Request

I stood in the grocery aisle waiting for Renee to say something that would make sense.

I had asked whether she really meant I should stay away on Christmas Day.

The question was still there.

I could hear the ordinary sounds of the store around me.

A shopping cart rolled somewhere behind me.

I looked down at my list again.

Potatoes.

Carrots.

Butter.

Cranberry sauce.

Four things I had expected to bring.

Four things I had believed would be useful.

I had not walked into the store expecting to have a conversation about whether I belonged at Christmas dinner.

I had walked in to buy groceries.

That was all.

I was still holding the telephone against my ear.

My shoulder had begun to ache from keeping it there.

I could have moved it into my hand.

For some reason, I did not.

I stayed exactly as I was, staring at the herbs.

One package of thyme was in my cart.

The other was back on the shelf.

I had chosen the discounted one.

There had been nothing wrong with its leaves.

I remembered examining them and wondering why anyone had marked them down.

It seemed ridiculous that I could remember something so small while struggling to understand what Renee had told me.

Her parents were coming.

They would arrive around noon.

The arrangements had already been made.

I repeated those facts silently.

I was trying to understand where I fitted into them.

There was a gathering.

There was a meal.

There were guests.

But apparently there was no place for me.

I had not heard anything about a shortage of chairs.

I had not heard anything about a shortage of food.

Renee had only said that they had everything covered.

That was why I had offered to bring something else.

I had thought she might name another dish.

Something simple.

Something that would make my trip to the grocery store worthwhile.

But she had not done that.

Instead, she had told me it would be better if I did not attend.

Better.

That was the word I kept thinking about.

Better for whom?

I had not asked her that question.

I had only repeated what I thought she meant.

There was a difference between those two questions.

One asked for an explanation.

The other asked whether I had understood.

At that moment, I could barely manage the second.

I was afraid of sounding foolish.

I was even more afraid of sounding hurt.

So I kept my voice as ordinary as I could.

I looked at the packages on the shelf.

Some were lined up neatly.

Others had been pushed backward.

The yellow sticker stood out against the plastic on the package in my cart.

Reduced.

That was what it said.

A word meant for groceries.

I tried not to give it any other meaning.

I knew the difference between a label and a person's intentions.

At least, I thought I did.

Renee had been very clear about the arrangements.

She had not said that Christmas was canceled.

She had not said the meal was moving to another day.

She had not said everyone would be getting together later.

She had said they were celebrating at their house with her parents.

And she had said I should not come.

I found myself wishing she had been less definite.

If she had sounded uncertain, I could have believed there was still something to discuss.

If she had asked what I thought, I could have answered.

But she had presented the decision as something already settled.

I did not know what had been said before she called me.

I did not know who had made the final arrangement.

I did not know whether anyone else had been part of that conversation.

I knew only what she had chosen to tell me.

That was an important distinction.

I wanted to fill in the missing pieces.

I wanted a reason.

I wanted something that would explain why a change in her mother's plans meant I could no longer attend Christmas dinner.

But wanting an explanation did not give me one.

I could not turn my guesses into facts.

I could not pretend I knew what Renee was thinking.

I could only listen to what she had said.

That was harder than I expected.

I had already accepted that her mother would arrive on a different day.

I had already accepted that the food was covered.

I had already offered to change what I brought.

I had accepted every practical adjustment she mentioned.

And still, I was being left out.

That was the part I could not make ordinary.

I moved my shopping list slightly so I could see the last item.

Cranberry sauce.

I had written it down with the others.

I wondered why I was still holding the paper.

There was no reason to keep studying it.

The list could not help me understand the conversation.

Yet I did not put it away.

Perhaps I needed something familiar in my hand.

Something that had made sense before the telephone rang.

I had believed I was preparing for Christmas.

Renee had called to tell me that Christmas had changed.

I was still trying to understand how much.

There was one thing I finally had to admit.

The problem was no longer what I should bring.

It was whether I was supposed to be there at all.

And the answer Renee had given me was no.


Click here to continue reading: PART 6: I Had Accepted Every Change Renee Mentioned Until I Realized None of My Offers Could Give Me Back Christmas Day

Story Parts

I Was Choosing Herbs for Christmas Dinner When Renee Called and Told Me Our Family Had Changed Its Plans

Part 5 of 10

Previous: Part 4
Next: Part 6

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *