PART 2 – Renee Had Already Arranged Christmas With Her Parents, but I Was Still Trying to Understand Why My Place Had Disappeared

What troubled me first was not the food.

It was how settled everything sounded.

Renee had not called to ask whether a different arrangement would suit me.

She had not asked what I thought.

She was telling me what had already been decided.

I could hear the difference.

Looking back, I think I understood more than I wanted to admit.

I simply did not want to be right.

There I was, in the grocery store, holding my shopping list.

And Renee was explaining a Christmas that apparently had no place for me.

I had been preparing for one kind of day.

She was describing another.

I tried to make the two fit together.

Her parents were coming.

That part was clear.

They would arrive around noon.

That part was clear too.

The plans had been made.

The food was arranged.

None of those things necessarily meant that I could not attend.

At least, that was what I told myself.

I kept returning to that small distinction.

Having enough food was not the same as having enough room.

Changing the guest arrangements was not the same as excluding somebody.

I wanted the conversation to remain about a practical problem.

Practical problems had practical answers.

If the potatoes were no longer needed, I could leave them at the store.

If the carrots were unnecessary, I could cross them off the list.

If cranberry sauce had already been bought, there was nothing to discuss.

But those were not the arrangements Renee was really changing.

I knew that when she told me to stay away.

I could not quite make myself respond to it.

The grocery list stayed in my hand.

I had written it because I expected to contribute.

That expectation seemed so small now.

I had not asked for anything special.

I had only been buying what I thought was needed.

I kept thinking about the twenty-sixth.

That had been the day I believed Renee's mother was coming.

It was such an ordinary detail.

A date.

Nothing more.

Yet I had remembered it because it mattered to the plans.

When Renee said her mother had changed her mind, I accepted it.

I did not question why.

I did not ask what had caused the change.

I simply moved on to the potatoes.

Perhaps that was why the next part came as such a shock.

I had been treating the conversation like a minor adjustment.

Renee had been leading me toward something much larger.

Or perhaps she had been trying to say it gently.

I could not know that from the few words she used.

All I knew was what she had told me.

Christmas would be at their house.

Her parents would be there.

The meal was covered.

And she thought I should not attend.

Those facts were enough.

I did not need to know anything else to understand that the Christmas I had expected was no longer happening.

Still, I wanted another explanation.

Something that would make the words less final.

Something that would turn them back into a question about food.

I had offered to bring something else.

I remember that particularly well.

It was such a hopeful little offer.

I was trying to find a way to remain useful.

I thought perhaps usefulness was the issue.

If they had everything they needed, I could bring something different.

I had no idea what that something would be.

It hardly mattered.

What mattered was that I was still trying to find a place at the meal.

Then Renee told me not to come.

And there was nothing left on my shopping list that could solve it.


Click here to continue reading: PART 3: The Potatoes Were Still Written on My Shopping List When I Finally Understood What Renee Was Asking Me to Accept

Story Parts

I Was Choosing Herbs for Christmas Dinner When Renee Called and Told Me Our Family Had Changed Its Plans

Part 2 of 10

Previous: Part 1
Next: Part 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *