PART 3 – The Potatoes Were Still Written on My Shopping List When I Finally Understood What Renee Was Asking Me to Accept

I kept looking at the potatoes.

Not real potatoes.

Just the word on the paper.

It was written near the beginning of my list.

Under it were carrots, butter, and cranberry sauce.

I had gone into the store expecting to buy those things.

I had expected to bring them to Christmas dinner.

That was why I was there.

I had no reason to think anything was wrong when Renee called.

I had answered while standing in front of the herbs.

I had continued shopping while she spoke.

That was how ordinary the call had seemed.

Until it wasn't.

There was a sound behind me.

Another shopping cart rolling past.

I remember hearing its wheels.

People were still moving through the store.

Nothing around me had changed.

That was the strange part.

I was standing in the same place.

Looking at the same shelves.

Holding the same paper.

But the conversation had made all those ordinary things feel suddenly out of place.

I had wanted to choose thyme.

I had wanted to finish my shopping.

Instead, I was trying to understand why Renee had told me to stay home.

I thought about asking another question.

Then another.

But I did not even know which one would help.

Was there a problem with the amount of food?

No.

She had already told me that everything was covered.

Was the date wrong?

No.

She had specifically said Christmas Day.

Had her parents changed their plans?

Yes.

That was the explanation she had given.

But it still did not explain why I could not be there.

I realized I had been answering questions she had not asked.

Offering food she did not need.

Finding solutions to problems she had not described.

I had been doing all that because the alternative was difficult to accept.

The alternative was simple.

I was not wanted at the Christmas meal.

I did not know why.

I did not know whether Renee understood what that meant to me.

I knew only that she had said it.

I remember taking the second package of thyme out of my hand and placing it back where I had found it.

I had already put the other one in my cart.

The decision was made.

One package.

Not two.

Such a tiny choice.

I could make that choice without difficulty.

I could decide which herbs to buy.

I could decide whether the discount was worthwhile.

I could decide what belonged in my cart.

But Renee had just told me that another decision was no longer mine to make.

That was what hurt.

It had already been settled.

There would be a Christmas gathering.

Her parents were expected at noon.

The food would be ready.

I would not be attending.

I had not been part of that decision.

I had only been informed of it.

For a moment, I wanted to believe that Renee had chosen the wrong words.

That she meant something less hurtful.

That she would correct herself if I gave her the chance.

So I repeated the part I could not accept.

I asked whether she really meant I should not come.

I had no clever response prepared.

No argument.

No accusation.

Just disbelief.

I had been thinking about potatoes when the telephone rang.

Now I was thinking about whether I had a place at Christmas.


Click here to continue reading: PART 4: I Had Offered to Bring Anything They Needed, but Renee’s Last Words Made the Real Problem Impossible to Ignore

Story Parts

I Was Choosing Herbs for Christmas Dinner When Renee Called and Told Me Our Family Had Changed Its Plans

Part 3 of 10

Previous: Part 2
Next: Part 4

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *