PART 1 – I Was Choosing Herbs for Christmas Dinner When Renee Called and Told Me Our Family Had Changed Its Plans

I thought I was still expected at Christmas dinner.

That was the mistake I made.

I was standing in the grocery store, holding two small packages of thyme, when Renee called.

One package had a yellow discount label.

The other did not.

I had been comparing them for longer than I needed to.

The leaves looked much the same to me.

I could not see why one cost less.

Still, I was trying to be careful.

Christmas dinner was coming, and I wanted to bring what I had promised.

My shopping list was already in my hand.

Potatoes.

Carrots.

Butter.

Cranberry sauce.

Ordinary things.

Things I understood.

I had my telephone pressed awkwardly against my ear while I examined the herbs.

Renee was speaking.

At first, I kept looking at the shelf.

Then her voice changed.

Not dramatically.

Just enough that I stopped comparing the packages.

She said there had been a change to Christmas.

I remember looking at the thyme.

I remember turning one package over.

I remember waiting for her to explain.

I asked what had changed.

She told me they had decided to celebrate at their house with her parents.

Her parents would arrive around midday.

Everything had already been organized.

I stood there trying to fit that information into what I had understood before the call.

I had expected her mother to visit on December twenty-sixth.

That was what I remembered.

So I mentioned it.

Renee said her mother had changed her plans.

Nothing more.

I accepted the explanation because there was no reason, yet, to do anything else.

Families changed arrangements.

People traveled on different days.

Meals were moved.

I understood all that.

Or thought I did.

I placed one package of thyme in my cart.

It seemed reasonable to continue shopping.

I still had potatoes to buy.

I still had carrots on my list.

I still believed that whatever had changed could be worked out.

That belief lasted only a few more seconds.

I asked Renee whether she still wanted me to bring the potatoes.

It was a simple question.

I had written them near the top of my list because I expected to need them.

Her answer was that the food had been taken care of.

I looked down at the paper.

There was something foolish about the way I kept checking those words.

Potatoes.

Carrots.

Butter.

Cranberry sauce.

As though the list might tell me what to say next.

I did not want to make a problem over food.

That was the last thing I wanted.

If someone else was making the potatoes, that was fine.

If another person had already bought everything, I could bring something different.

I said so.

Renee did not immediately offer another suggestion.

I noticed that.

I noticed it without understanding what it meant.

Then she said my name.

That was when I finally stopped thinking about the groceries.

She told me it would be better if I stayed away on Christmas Day.

I did not answer at once.

I had heard her.

Every word.

But hearing something and accepting what it means are not always the same thing.

I looked at the thyme in my cart.

Then I took my eyes off it.

There was another package still in my hand.

For a moment, I could not remember why I had picked it up.

I returned it to the shelf.

Carefully.

That is one detail I have never forgotten.

I put the thyme back as though the decision about herbs still mattered.

As though I needed to finish one ordinary task before dealing with what Renee had just said.

Then I asked her to repeat what she meant.

Because surely I had misunderstood.

Surely she was talking about the meal.

Or the time.

Or the potatoes.

Anything except Christmas itself.

But I had heard her correctly.

She did not want me to come.


Click here to continue reading: PART 2: Renee Had Already Arranged Christmas With Her Parents, but I Was Still Trying to Understand Why My Place Had Disappeared

Story Parts

I Was Choosing Herbs for Christmas Dinner When Renee Called and Told Me Our Family Had Changed Its Plans

Part 1 of 10

Next: Part 2

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *