PART 5 – MY HUSBAND KEPT STARING AT THE WINDOW AFTER HE HEARD ABOUT THE GOATS, BUT THE REAL ANSWER WAS STILL ON OUR KITCHEN TABLE

Alden didn't move away from the window.

I remained at the kitchen table.

The lease lay between us, exactly where he had dropped it.

Neither of us had touched it since.

For a while, the only thing I could hear was the faint movement outside near the fence.

I knew what had made the sound.

I had already told him.

Goats.

Such a simple word.

Yet Alden looked as though I had told him something he couldn't quite believe.

He turned his head toward me.

Then he looked outside again.

I waited for him to speak.

He didn't.

That was unusual enough to make me uncomfortable.

For forty-five years, I had grown accustomed to Alden having something to say about nearly everything that concerned our home and land.

He asked questions.

He made statements.

He offered conclusions before I had finished explaining.

And most of the time, I allowed him to finish.

Now he seemed unable to decide which question to ask first.

I looked down at the paper.

My name was printed there.

Joanne Kittle.

I had read those words before.

They weren't new to me.

But watching Alden struggle with them had given them a different weight.

I hadn't changed the deed during our conversation.

I hadn't changed the lease.

I hadn't suddenly become the owner because I had spoken firmly.

The document stated something that was already true.

That distinction mattered.

I wished I had understood it more clearly years earlier.

Perhaps I had understood it.

Perhaps I had simply been unwilling to say it aloud.

There were things a person could know without ever allowing them to become part of a conversation.

I had become good at that.

Too good.

Alden finally turned away from the window.

He looked down at the lease again.

I recognized the expression on his face.

He wasn't ready to accept my answer.

But he hadn't found another one.

I said nothing.

The paper remained open on the table.

The agreement identified me as the owner of forty acres in Marion County, Arkansas.

It named Miriam Yoder as the other party.

Its purpose concerned the pasture.

There was no mystery about any of that.

I had explained it.

Still, I could see Alden trying to fit those facts into the version of our marriage he had always understood.

I didn't know how he would manage it.

And for once, I didn't feel responsible for making the task easier.

That realization came quietly.

I didn't smile.

I didn't congratulate myself.

I simply noticed that I wasn't reaching for an apology.

Usually, that would have been my first instinct.

Alden could become upset, and I would begin searching for words to settle him.

Even when I had done nothing wrong.

Especially then.

I used to tell myself I was being practical.

There was no point arguing about every little thing.

A peaceful evening mattered more than being right.

That was what I had believed.

But standing up for a fact wasn't the same as picking a fight.

I was beginning to understand that.

The lease was a fact.

The deed was a fact.

The goats outside were a fact.

Alden's disbelief didn't erase any of them.

He shifted his weight.

I glanced toward the window.

The fence was outside, beyond the kitchen.

Nothing about it looked different from where I sat.

Yet the sound that had come from that direction had changed the conversation.

Alden was no longer laughing at me.

He wasn't calling the pasture his.

At least not at that moment.

He was standing there with a puzzled expression, trying to understand what he had heard.

I didn't know whether the goats concerned him more than the lease.

I could only see that both had caught him by surprise.

I folded my hands again.

Then I stopped.

I had been doing that all evening.

Holding them together.

Keeping them still.

As though I needed to prove I could sit through a disagreement without becoming frightened of it.

I placed my palms flat against the table instead.

The surface felt solid beneath them.

I looked at the agreement.

For years, I had allowed Alden's certainty to make me doubt my own words.

He could say something belonged to him, and I would begin searching for a softer way to disagree.

I knew that habit didn't make sense.

But habits didn't always have to make sense to survive.

Sometimes they only had to become familiar.

I had been familiar with silence.

With yielding.

With deciding that the next disagreement wasn't worth the trouble.

And I had lived that way for so long that I sometimes forgot there were other choices.

That evening, the choice had been simple.

I could let Alden call the pasture his.

Or I could correct him.

I had corrected him.

Nothing more.

Nothing less.

He hadn't liked it.

But I was still sitting there.

The room hadn't fallen apart.

The truth remained where it had been.

I looked up at him.

He was still watching the window.

I wondered whether he had heard another movement outside.

I listened.

For a moment, there was nothing.

Then came another faint sound near the fence.

It was enough to make him turn his head.

I didn't repeat myself.

I had already answered his question.

There was something almost strange about allowing an answer to stand without defending it.

I could feel the old temptation.

Explain more.

Make him comfortable.

Tell him everything in a way that won't upset him.

But I stayed quiet.

Miriam Yoder's name was on the paper.

So was mine.

Alden could read both.

He didn't need me to pretend the words meant something else.

I looked at the overhead light.

It illuminated the table and the document.

I had never thought much about that light.

It was simply part of our kitchen.

But I would remember it.

I would remember the way Alden stood beneath it with the lease in his hand.

I would remember his face when he read my name.

And I would remember how quickly his laughter stopped when the conversation refused to go the way he expected.

Those were small details.

But they mattered to me.

Not because I wanted to punish him.

I didn't.

I wanted him to understand what the document said.

And I wanted to stop behaving as though my ownership was something I needed to hide.

The two desires were connected.

I couldn't ask Alden to acknowledge what belonged to me if I kept avoiding the words myself.

That was the uncomfortable truth.

I had a part in the silence that had grown between us.

Not in the deed.

Not in the facts.

But in the way those facts had been discussed.

I had allowed his assumptions to go unanswered.

Now one conversation had brought them into the open.

I didn't know what Alden would do with that.

He might remain angry.

He might ask the same question again.

He might return to the word he liked so much.

His.

But I knew what I would say.

The answer hadn't changed.

I owned the forty acres.

The lease was between me and Miriam Yoder.

And the goats were outside near the fence.

I wasn't going to turn those facts into an argument about whether I loved or respected my husband.

They were simply facts.

Alden looked back toward the table.

His eyes settled on the agreement.

He seemed to be considering it again.

I let him.

There was no need to hurry him toward a conclusion.

No reason to fill every quiet moment.

For the first time that evening, I felt able to wait without preparing a defense.

That was a small change.

But it was mine.

I stayed seated while Alden looked at the paper.

And when he finally lifted his eyes toward me again, I met his gaze without looking away.


Click here to continue reading: PART 6: THE LEASE HAD NOT CHANGED, BUT I BEGAN TO UNDERSTAND HOW MUCH OF MY MARRIAGE HAD BEEN BUILT AROUND A SINGLE WORD

Story Parts

MY HUSBAND HELD A PIECE OF PAPER IN OUR KITCHEN, AND I KNEW FORTY-FIVE YEARS OF SILENCE WERE ABOUT TO END

Part 5 of 10

Previous: Part 4
Next: Part 6

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *