PART 4 – A STRANGE SOUND CAME FROM THE FENCE WHILE ALDEN QUESTIONED MY LEASE, AND ONE SMALL ANSWER CHANGED HIS EXPRESSION AGAIN

Alden turned toward the kitchen window.

The paper was on the table now.

The argument had not been settled.

But something outside had interrupted it.

He stood very still.

I heard the noise again.

A faint jingling sound came from the direction of the fence.

It wasn't particularly loud.

Still, in the quiet after our disagreement, it was easy to notice.

Alden looked toward the window.

He seemed to be trying to identify it.

I knew what had made the noise.

I didn't say anything immediately.

For the first time that evening, Alden was listening to something other than his own objections.

I watched him.

His expression was different now.

He wasn't laughing.

He wasn't looking at the document.

He was looking outside.

The lease between me and Miriam Yoder remained on the table.

I glanced at it.

It was strange how quickly that simple sheet of paper had changed the atmosphere in our kitchen.

A few minutes earlier, Alden had been reading it aloud.

Then he had stopped at my name.

He had asked why he wasn't included.

And I had told him the truth.

Now we were sitting with the consequences of that answer.

Neither of us had taken back a word.

That mattered to me.

I had spent too many years thinking that keeping a marriage peaceful meant making every disagreement disappear as quickly as possible.

Sometimes I had been willing to accept a misunderstanding just to avoid the argument that might follow.

I could see that now.

I didn't like it.

But I could see it.

That evening, I wasn't prepared to do it again.

Alden had called the pasture his.

I had said it belonged to me.

He had disliked hearing that.

But his displeasure didn't change the deed.

It didn't change the agreement.

And it didn't put his name where mine appeared.

The sound outside came again.

Alden's eyebrows drew together.

He kept his eyes on the window.

"What keeps making that sound?"

I looked at him.

I could have explained more.

I could have begun talking about the pasture lease.

I could have returned to the document and pointed out the names again.

But that wasn't what he'd asked.

He wanted to know what was outside.

So I answered the question.

"The goats."

That was all.

Two words.

Alden turned back toward me.

He stared.

I could see the surprise on his face.

It was different from the look he'd given me when he read the lease.

Before, he had been trying to understand why my name appeared as the owner.

Now he was trying to take in the sound from outside and the answer I had just given him.

Goats.

I let the word stand.

I didn't rush to explain what it meant.

I didn't apologize for them being there.

The lease was still on the table.

Its purpose was clear.

It concerned the use of pasture.

It named Miriam Yoder as the other party.

And it identified me as the person who owned the forty acres.

Those facts hadn't changed because Alden was upset.

The animals outside were real too.

The faint sound against the fence had been enough to bring them into the kitchen conversation without anyone opening a door.

I found that almost unbelievable.

We had argued over words on paper.

Ownership.

Names.

A pasture.

And then a small noise from outside had made Alden turn away from the argument.

I watched his face.

He hadn't said anything yet.

I recognized the pause.

It was the same hesitation I'd seen when he first reached the line naming me as the sole owner.

He had expected the world to be arranged one way.

Now he was facing something that didn't match that expectation.

I didn't know exactly what he would say next.

And I didn't pretend I did.

I knew only what had happened.

He had read the agreement between me and Miriam Yoder.

He had questioned why his own name was missing.

I had explained that the property deed did not name him.

He had laughed.

He had claimed the pasture as his.

I had corrected him.

Then the noise outside had caught his attention.

And I had told him what made it.

The goats.

It was such an ordinary answer.

I couldn't help thinking about that.

Nothing about the word was grand.

It didn't sound like the ending of a forty-five-year argument.

It didn't settle what Alden might say about the lease afterward.

And it certainly didn't tell me whether he would accept the truth about the land.

But it was the answer.

There was no benefit in dressing it up.

Alden continued looking at me.

I didn't turn away.

That, more than anything, was what I remembered.

I wasn't speaking loudly.

I wasn't trying to embarrass him.

I wasn't asking for praise or permission.

I was sitting in my own kitchen, answering questions about a lease bearing my name.

The truth didn't require a performance.

Not from me.

Not anymore.

I looked at the document lying on the table.

Forty acres in Marion County, Arkansas.

Joanne Kittle.

Miriam Yoder.

A lease concerning the pasture.

All of it had been there from the beginning of the conversation.

The only thing that had changed was Alden's awareness of it.

I could feel the weight of that difference.

For years, what he believed about the farm had seemed more important in our conversations than anything I might say about it.

Now the written agreement contradicted his assumption.

He could dislike the words.

He could be astonished by them.

He could laugh at me for pointing them out.

But he couldn't make them disappear.

I looked back at him.

His eyes were wide.

His attention moved between me and the window.

I didn't know whether he was more surprised by the goats or by the fact that I had answered without asking him what he thought.

Perhaps it was both.

I couldn't read his mind.

I could only sit there and see what his face told me.

He was stunned.

And I was no longer trying to rescue him from that feeling.

There was nothing more I needed to say in that moment.

The pasture lease lay where he had put it.

The fence stood outside.

The goats had made their presence known.

And Alden, who had spent the evening demanding an explanation, was standing in our kitchen without another word.

I remained at the table.

For the moment, I let the silence belong to him.


Click here to continue reading: PART 5: MY HUSBAND KEPT STARING AT THE WINDOW AFTER HE HEARD ABOUT THE GOATS, BUT THE REAL ANSWER WAS STILL ON OUR KITCHEN TABLE

Story Parts

MY HUSBAND HELD A PIECE OF PAPER IN OUR KITCHEN, AND I KNEW FORTY-FIVE YEARS OF SILENCE WERE ABOUT TO END

Part 4 of 10

Previous: Part 3
Next: Part 5

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *