Robert didn't answer me right away.
I could hear the television behind him.
Somebody on the screen was laughing.
It sounded like one of those Christmas programs Mary used to watch while she folded wrapping paper.
I waited for my son to speak.
Then he sighed.
"Dad, what exactly did Tommy tell you?"
I looked at the unfinished ribbon on Sophie's doll.
"He said I wasn't welcome at your house."
Robert didn't seem surprised.
"Well, we decided to keep Christmas quiet this year."
"That's not what you told me last week."
"Dad, plans change."
I rubbed my forehead.
"Then why did Tommy sound frightened?"
There was another pause.
This one lasted longer.
"He's upset because he's being disciplined."
I straightened in my chair.
"Disciplined for what?"
"He's been acting out."
"How?"
Robert made an impatient sound.
"He's twelve, Dad. Kids that age get difficult."
I knew Tommy could be stubborn.
He had once refused to leave my workshop until he finished building a birdhouse.
But stubborn wasn't the same thing as frightened.
I remembered the little voice that had whispered into my telephone.
"She's coming."
I asked Robert whether Jennifer was home.
"Of course she's home. It's Christmas Eve."
"Can I speak to Tommy?"
"No."
The answer came too quickly.
I waited.
Robert didn't explain.
"Why not?"
"Because he's grounded."
"Grounded children can still speak to their grandfathers."
"Dad, you're not going to tell me how to raise my son."
I hadn't raised my voice.
I hadn't accused him of anything.
But Robert was already speaking as though we were having an argument.
That bothered me.
"Is he sick?"
"No."
"Did something happen at school?"
"No."
"Then let me talk to him for a minute."
I heard movement behind Robert.
A chair scraped.
The television became quieter.
Then a woman's voice said something I couldn't make out.
Jennifer.
I recognized her voice immediately.
Robert covered the telephone.
I heard a muffled conversation.
Then he returned.
"Tommy's fine."
"Let him tell me that."
"He's not available."
"Robert."
"What?"
"Where is my grandson?"
The question came out more sharply than I intended.
Robert seemed to notice.
"He's in his room."
"Then go upstairs and get him."
"Dad, stop."
I closed my eyes.
Mary used to tell me that Robert became defensive when he was worried about losing control of a conversation.
She said he had been that way since he was little.
I remembered her saying it after one of our arguments about his first car.
Back then, the worst thing he had done was drive too fast.
Now I was trying to find out why his son sounded afraid.
I kept my voice low.
"Listen carefully, Robert. Tommy called me because something upset him. I want to know he's safe."
"He is safe."
"Then there's no reason I can't speak to him."
Jennifer's voice returned in the background.
This time I heard my name.
"Joe needs to mind his own business."
Robert didn't correct her.
He didn't even move away from the telephone.
I sat there listening.
There had been a time when my son would never have allowed somebody to speak about me that way.
I didn't know exactly when things had changed.
Maybe it happened slowly enough that I failed to notice.
After Mary's funeral, Robert began calling less often.
At first I thought he wanted space.
He had lost his mother too.
I understood grief could make people quiet.
But one missed call became several.
Then the visits stopped.
And now my grandson was afraid to use the telephone.
"Robert, I'm coming over."
"No, you're not."
"I have Christmas gifts for the children."
"Bring them another day."
"Tommy needs to see me."
"You don't know what Tommy needs."
His words hurt.
Not because I expected to make every decision for my grandchildren.
I didn't.
But I had been part of Tommy's life since the day he was born.
I had held him in the hospital while Mary stood beside me crying.
I had taught him how to tie fishing knots.
I had taken him to baseball practice when Robert worked late.
He had spent summer afternoons in my garage, handing me tools he couldn't yet name.
And now my son was telling me I didn't know him.
I looked toward the kitchen clock.
The hands seemed to be moving faster than before.
"Tell Tommy I love him."
Robert sighed again.
"Dad, don't make this dramatic."
"Just tell him."
There was silence.
Then Robert said something I have never forgotten.
"He doesn't need you confusing him right now."
I felt a tightness in my chest.
"Confusing him about what?"
"About family."
I waited for him to explain.
He didn't.
Instead, I heard Jennifer say something about dinner getting cold.
Robert lowered his voice.
"We're having a peaceful Christmas, Dad. Please don't ruin it."
I stared at the telephone.
A peaceful Christmas.
That was what he called it.
I thought about Tommy whispering because he was afraid somebody would hear him.
"Can you at least tell me why he wasn't supposed to call?"
Robert didn't answer.
I repeated the question.
"Why isn't Tommy allowed to telephone me?"
"Because he keeps trying to get around our rules."
"What rules?"
"Good night, Dad."
The line disconnected.
I remained seated with the receiver against my ear.
For the second time that evening, someone in Robert's house had ended a conversation before I could finish.
I put the telephone down.
Then I picked it up again.
I considered calling back.
But I knew what would happen.
Robert would either refuse to answer or repeat the same things.
Tommy was fine.
Tommy was grounded.
Tommy was difficult.
Nothing was wrong.
I had heard all of it.
What I hadn't heard was my grandson's voice.
I stood up.
My chair moved backward against the kitchen floor.
I walked to the window above the sink.
Outside, the yard was dark.
A little snow remained along the fence.
Mary had always liked seeing snow on Christmas Eve.
She said it made the lights from the neighbors' houses look warmer.
I looked down at the ring on my finger.
It slipped when I turned my hand.
I pushed it back into place.
"Mary," I said quietly, "I don't know what Robert is doing."
There was no answer.
Of course there wasn't.
But speaking her name helped me make the next decision.
I went back to the table.
The utility bill was still folded in my shirt pocket.
I took it out.
Forty-two dollars.
Due on the fourth.
I placed it beside the telephone.
Then I checked the oven.
The turkey was cooked.
I turned off the heat.
I didn't have much appetite.
I put the roasting pan aside and covered it.
The gravy would have to wait.
I returned to Sophie's doll.
The ribbon was still twisted.
I pulled it loose and tied it again.
This time I made a simple bow.
Nothing fancy.
Just two loops and a knot that would hold.
I placed the doll with Tommy's gifts.
His present was wrapped in green paper.
I had bought him a small set of tools because he had been asking about helping me repair the old workbench.
There was also a book Mary had chosen for him before she died.
I had kept it wrapped all these months.
I hadn't been sure whether giving it to him on Christmas would make him sad.
Now I thought he might need it.
I carried the presents into the hallway.
Then I opened the closet.
My winter coat hung beside several shirts I rarely wore anymore.
I reached past the gray one.
Behind it was a blue shirt.
I hadn't worn it since Robert's wedding.
Mary had chosen it for me.
She said the color made me look less tired.
I took it from the hanger.
For a moment, I held it against my chest.
I remembered Robert standing beside me on his wedding day.
He had been nervous.
His hands shook when he straightened his tie.
I had put one hand on his shoulder.
"You're going to be fine, son."
He had smiled.
"I know, Dad."
I wanted to remember that young man.
The one who had looked at me with trust.
The one who had promised to take care of his family.
I wasn't sure what had happened to him.
But I knew what I was going to do.
I changed into the blue shirt.
Then I buttoned my coat.
I gathered the presents.
And I carried them outside to my old gray Ford.
Click here to continue reading: PART 6: I Drove North In My Old Gray Ford Wearing The Blue Shirt From Robert’s Wedding And Found A House That Looked Perfect From The Street
My Grandson Called Three Minutes Late On Christmas Eve, And The Fear In His Voice Made Me Forget Everything Else
Part 5 of 10
