PART 2 – Arnold Finally Told Me Where Ben Was, but His Explanation Made the Apple Pie in My Hand Feel Like a Terrible Mistake

I looked at Arnold and waited for him to finish.

He had told me Ben was upstairs.

That should have been enough.

It wasn't.

"Why won't you just tell me what's going on?"

Arnold lowered his eyes.

"Ben asked us not to get in touch with you."

For a moment, I didn't understand.

I thought I had heard him incorrectly.

"With me?"

Arnold nodded.

I looked at him, waiting for a correction.

There wasn't one.

My husband had told people at the hospital not to contact me.

I could hardly make sense of those words.

I wasn't a stranger asking for private information.

I was his wife.

I had come to see him.

I had a homemade pie in my hand.

And somehow, that visit had become something other people had been warned about.

I asked Arnold to explain.

He looked uncomfortable.

I didn't blame him for that.

But I needed him to continue.

"He said that if you came here asking for him, we were supposed to…"

Arnold stopped before finishing.

I stared at him.

"Supposed to do what?"

He looked at me for another moment.

"Let him have a little time."

I almost laughed before I could help myself.

It wasn't because anything was funny.

I simply couldn't believe what I was hearing.

"Time?"

Arnold said nothing.

I repeated the word.

"What does that even mean?"

He still didn't answer.

I looked down at the lunch bag.

I had spent twenty minutes cutting apples for that pie.

I remembered being careful with every slice.

I remembered wanting to make something Ben would enjoy.

I remembered the note.

I had rewritten it because I didn't want it to sound too serious.

Such a ridiculous concern.

I had worried about the tone of a little note while my husband had apparently been making arrangements to avoid me.

That hurt.

I didn't want Arnold to see how much.

I held the bag a little more tightly.

I could feel myself struggling to keep my voice steady.

There were questions I wanted to ask.

Had Ben been expecting me?

How had he known I might come?

Why would he tell other people not to call me?

And what was so important about giving him time?

But I didn't ask all of them.

I could barely manage one.

"Arnold, what have I walked into?"

He looked at me.

His eyes were wet.

That frightened me.

Until then, I had been trying to understand Ben's behavior.

Now I was trying to understand Arnold's reaction.

He looked as though he was carrying something painful.

Something he wasn't ready to say.

I wanted him to tell me there had been a misunderstanding.

I wanted him to explain that Ben had been busy.

Or that he had given instructions Arnold had misunderstood.

Anything ordinary.

Anything that would make the little bag in my hand feel reasonable again.

But Arnold didn't correct himself.

He didn't say Ben had changed his mind.

He didn't tell me to go upstairs.

He just stood there.

And I was left with the one fact he had finally admitted.

Ben had deliberately asked them not to contact me.

I thought about the way Arnold had paused before telling me.

He hadn't seemed uncertain about the instruction.

He had seemed uncertain about whether he should repeat it.

There was a difference.

A terrible difference.

I looked at the bag again.

The pie was meant to make Ben smile.

Now I didn't even know whether he would want to receive it.

I couldn't understand how an ordinary surprise had turned into this.

I had come expecting to see my husband.

Instead, I had learned that he had prepared other people for the possibility of my arrival.

I tried to speak again.

Nothing came out.

Arnold's eyes filled further.

And for the first time since I had walked into the hospital, I stopped thinking about the lunch I had brought.

I needed to understand what Ben was hiding.

But Arnold's expression told me that whatever remained unsaid wasn't simple.


Click here to continue reading: PART 3: I Found My Husband’s Handwritten Letter in Arnold’s Hand, and What It Revealed About a Missing Little Girl Changed Everything I Believed About Ben

Story Parts

I Went to Surprise My Husband With His Favorite Homemade Apple Pie, Never Expecting to Learn He Had Asked People to Keep Me Away

Part 2 of 10

Previous: Part 1
Next: Part 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *